If you are considering debt review, you have probably seen plenty of marketing promising it will solve all your problems. But you are smart enough to know there are two sides to every story. Here is the honest truth about debt review — the good, the bad, and everything in between — so you can make an informed decision about whether it is right for you.
We are a debt counselling company, so yes — we believe in debt review. But we also believe you deserve the full picture. No sugarcoating, no fine print. Just straight talk about what debt review can and cannot do for you.
What Is Debt Review? (Quick Recap)
Debt review — also called debt counselling — is a legal process under the National Credit Act (Section 86) that allows over-indebted South Africans to restructure their debt into one reduced monthly payment. A registered debt counsellor negotiates with your creditors on your behalf to lower your interest rates and extend your payment terms. The restructured payment plan is then enforced by a court order, which gives it the force of law.
For a full explanation of how the process works step by step, read our complete guide to debt review.
The Pros — Why 717,495 South Africans Are Under Debt Review
Debt review has become the most widely used formal debt relief mechanism in South Africa — and for good reason. Here are the genuine advantages.
1. Reduced Monthly Repayments (Up to 50%)
Your combined monthly debt payments are restructured to an affordable amount based on what you can actually afford after essential living expenses. Interest rates are reduced and payment terms are extended. In practice, unsecured debt repayments (credit cards, personal loans, store accounts) are typically reduced to approximately 45% of what you are currently paying, while secured debt (vehicle finance, home loans) is reduced to approximately 75% of current instalments. For many families, this means the difference between having enough for food and not.
2. Legal Protection from Creditors
Once you are under debt review, creditors cannot take legal action against you. No garnishee orders, no summons, no harassing phone calls. This is not just a promise from a debt counsellor — it is enforced by a court order under the National Credit Act. As long as you keep up with your restructured payments, your creditors are legally bound to accept the new arrangement. For anyone who has lived with the constant fear of a sheriff at the door, this protection is life-changing.
3. Your Assets Are Protected
Your home, car, and possessions cannot be repossessed while you are under debt review and maintaining your restructured payments. For many South Africans, this is the single most important benefit. You have worked hard for what you have — debt review ensures you keep it while you get your finances back on track. Without this protection, creditors can and do repossess vehicles and foreclose on homes.
4. One Simple Monthly Payment
Instead of juggling 5, 10, or 15 different creditors with different due dates, different amounts, and different bank accounts, you make one single payment to a registered Payment Distribution Agency (PDA). The PDA then distributes your payment to all your creditors on your behalf. Less administration, less confusion, and far less chance of missing a payment because you forgot which account was due when.
5. Lower Interest Rates
Your debt counsellor negotiates reduced interest rates with each of your creditors as part of the restructuring process. Unsecured debt interest rates in South Africa can be 24% or higher annually — and when you are only making minimum payments at those rates, most of your money goes to interest rather than actually reducing your debt. Under debt review, these rates are often significantly reduced, meaning more of every rand you pay goes towards actually paying off what you owe.
6. A Clear Path to Debt-Free
Unlike paying minimums and hoping for the best, debt review gives you a defined timeline — typically 3 to 5 years — with a guaranteed end date. You know exactly when you will be debt-free. When all your debts are settled, you receive a clearance certificate from your debt counsellor confirming that you are officially debt-free and the debt review flag is removed from your credit record. There is no ambiguity, no guesswork — just a clear finish line.
7. No New Loan Required
Unlike debt consolidation, you do not need to take out a new loan or have a good credit score to qualify for debt review. Your existing debts are restructured — not replaced with new debt. Debt review is designed specifically for people who are already over-indebted and would not qualify for new credit even if they wanted to. This makes it accessible to the people who need it most.
8. Mental Health Relief
Research shows that 67% of South Africans constantly worry about debt. Financial stress causes anxiety, insomnia, depression, and relationship breakdown. Having a structured repayment plan, legal protection from creditors, and the knowledge that there is a light at the end of the tunnel provides genuine peace of mind. Many of our clients report sleeping better within weeks of starting the process — not because the debt is gone yet, but because they finally have a plan and someone in their corner.
The Cons — What They Do Not Always Tell You
No solution is perfect, and you deserve to know the downsides before you commit. Here are the genuine disadvantages of debt review — honestly presented.
1. You Cannot Take On New Credit
While under debt review, you are legally restricted from taking on any new credit — no new loans, no credit cards, no store accounts, no vehicle finance. This is the biggest lifestyle impact and it lasts until you receive your clearance certificate, which typically takes 3 to 5 years. For some people, this restriction feels severe. But consider the alternative: if you are already over-indebted, taking on more credit is the very thing that got you into trouble in the first place.
2. It Takes Time (3-5 Years)
Debt review is not a quick fix. The average process takes 3 to 5 years depending on the total amount of debt, your income, and the repayment plan negotiated with your creditors. If you are looking for an overnight solution, this is not it — but then again, no legitimate debt solution is. The time it takes is the time it takes to actually repay what you owe at a rate you can afford. There are no shortcuts when it comes to real debt relief.
3. Your Credit Record Is Flagged
While under debt review, a "debt review" flag is placed on your credit profile at all credit bureaus (TransUnion, Experian, XDS, and Compuscan). This means you will appear as "under debt counselling" to anyone who checks your credit record — including potential employers and landlords in some cases. The flag is removed when you receive your clearance certificate and your debts are fully settled. It is worth noting, however, that if you are already missing payments and defaulting on accounts, your credit record is already damaged.
4. All Debts Must Be Included
You cannot cherry-pick which debts to include in the debt review process. All your credit agreements must be part of the restructured repayment plan. You cannot keep one credit card "just in case" or exclude your store account because you still want to use it. This is a legal requirement under the National Credit Act and ensures that the process is comprehensive. While this may feel restrictive, it is actually designed to protect you — keeping some debts outside the process would undermine the affordability of the whole plan.
5. There Are Fees
Debt counselling is not free. However, the fees are strictly regulated by the National Credit Regulator (NCR) and are transparent: a R50 application fee, a R300 administration fee, a restructuring fee equal to your first instalment (max R8,000 single / R9,000 joint COP), and an aftercare fee of 5% of your monthly instalment (max R450 per month). The important thing to understand is that these fees are included in your restructured monthly payment — you do not pay them separately or upfront. Your debt counsellor is paid from the same payment you make each month, so there are no surprise costs.
6. Withdrawing Has Consequences
If you decide to withdraw from debt review before completion, you lose all legal protection immediately. Creditors can pursue legal action, apply for garnishee orders against your salary, and repossess your assets. Your original unreduced interest rates and payment terms are reinstated. Some creditors may even demand the difference between the reduced amounts you have been paying and what you originally owed under the old terms. Withdrawing from debt review is not something to do on a whim — it should only be considered if your financial situation has genuinely improved to the point where you can afford all your original repayments.
7. Not Everyone Qualifies
You need to be genuinely over-indebted to qualify for debt review. This means your expenses and debt repayments must exceed your income. If your debt is manageable and you can afford your monthly payments — even if it is tight — a debt counsellor will tell you so. This is actually a good thing: it means the process has integrity and is not applied to people who do not genuinely need it. If you do not qualify, your debt counsellor should advise you on alternative strategies such as budgeting adjustments or negotiating directly with creditors.
Struggling With Debt?
Find out if you qualify for debt review in 60 seconds. Free, confidential, no obligation.
Start Free WhatsApp AssessmentPros vs Cons — Side by Side
Here is a clear summary of the advantages and disadvantages of debt review at a glance.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Monthly repayments reduced by up to 50% | Cannot take on new credit during the process |
| Legal protection from creditors (court order) | Process takes 3-5 years |
| Assets protected from repossession | Credit record flagged as "under debt review" |
| One simple monthly payment | All debts must be included |
| Lower interest rates negotiated | Regulated fees apply (included in payment) |
| Clear timeline to becoming debt-free | Withdrawing removes all protection |
| No new loan required | Must be genuinely over-indebted to qualify |
| Peace of mind and reduced stress |
Is Debt Review Worth It? How to Decide
The answer depends entirely on your personal financial situation. Here is an honest decision framework to help you work out whether debt review is the right move for you.
Debt Review IS Right for You If...
- Your total debt repayments exceed what you can afford each month
- You are worried about losing your home or car to repossession
- Creditors are threatening legal action or garnishee orders
- You are using one credit card to pay another
- You are borrowing money for essentials like food and petrol
- You cannot see a way out on your own
Debt Review May NOT Be Right for You If...
- You can afford your monthly repayments but just want lower interest rates — refinancing may be a better option
- You need access to new credit in the next 3 to 5 years, for example if you are planning to buy a house
- You only have one or two small debts that you could pay off quickly with a budget adjustment
- Your debt is manageable but you are not budgeting effectively — start with a budget first
The bottom line: If you are lying awake at night worrying about debt, if creditors are calling, if you are robbing Peter to pay Paul — debt review is almost certainly worth it. The temporary restrictions on new credit are a small price to pay for legal protection, reduced payments, and a guaranteed path to being debt-free. The cons are real, but they are manageable. The consequences of doing nothing — garnishee orders, repossession, mounting interest, and constant stress — are far worse.
Take the First Step
If you have read through the pros and cons and you think debt review might be right for you, here is what to do next:
- Use our free debt review calculator to see exactly how much you could save — no sign-up required, results in 30 seconds. Try the calculator now
- Chat to us on WhatsApp 24/7 for a free, confidential assessment of your situation — no obligation, no pressure
- A registered debt counsellor will give you an honest assessment. If debt review is not right for you, we will tell you — and suggest alternatives that might work better
The hardest part is making the decision to get help. Everything after that gets easier.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the main advantages of debt review?
The main advantages of debt review are: your monthly repayments are reduced by up to 50%, you receive court-ordered legal protection from creditors, your assets (home, car, possessions) are protected from repossession, all your debts are combined into one affordable monthly payment, your interest rates are reduced through negotiation, and you have a clear timeline (typically 3-5 years) to becoming completely debt-free with a clearance certificate at the end.
What are the disadvantages of debt review?
The main disadvantages of debt review are: you cannot take on any new credit while under review (no loans, credit cards, or store accounts), the process takes 3-5 years to complete, your credit record is flagged as "under debt review" at all credit bureaus, all your credit agreements must be included (you cannot choose which debts to include), there are regulated fees (included in your monthly payment), and if you withdraw before completion you lose all legal protection.
Is debt review worth it in South Africa?
If you are genuinely over-indebted — meaning your debt repayments exceed what you can afford each month — then debt review is almost certainly worth it. More than 717,495 South Africans are currently under debt review. The court-ordered legal protection alone is invaluable if creditors are threatening legal action or repossession. The temporary restrictions on new credit are a small price to pay for reduced payments, protected assets, and a guaranteed path to being debt-free.
Can I cancel debt review if I change my mind?
Yes, you can withdraw from debt review, but there are serious consequences. You immediately lose all legal protection, meaning creditors can pursue legal action, garnishee orders, and asset repossession. Your original (unreduced) interest rates and payment terms are reinstated. Some creditors may even demand the difference between the reduced amounts you have been paying and what you originally owed. Withdrawing from debt review should be a last resort, not a casual decision.
How long does debt review stay on my credit record?
The "under debt review" flag remains on your credit record for the duration of the debt review process, which typically takes 3-5 years. Once all your debts are settled and your debt counsellor issues a clearance certificate, the flag is removed from your credit record at all credit bureaus. After that, you are free to apply for new credit and can begin rebuilding your credit score.
